Home / Reports / cs-product-manager

cs-product-manager

Validated 5 Jun 2026 · Repository
PRO
0
Poor
0 critical
20 warnings
10 suggestions
79 passed
Domain scores
Anti-Slop
80
Accessibility
100
Enterprise
100
Issues

Warnings (20)

5.1-no-style-sectionline 1
No writing style section found
Fix: Add a '## Writing Style' or '## Anti-Slop' section
16.1-no-stop-conditionline 10
Complex skill lacks explicit stop conditions
Fix: Add stop/termination criteria (e.g., 'Stop after N iterations', 'Abort if error rate exceeds threshold')
2.1-lines-warningline 10
Body exceeds 500 lines (got 676)
Fix: Consider condensing or splitting content
19.4-inversion-no-questionsline 10
Inversion pattern detected but no question framework documented
Fix: Document what questions the skill asks and when it stops asking
19.3-generator-no-output-specline 10
Generator pattern detected but no output format specified
Fix: Document the output format (template, schema, or example output)
4.5-desc-no-triggersline 2
Description lacks triggering conditions
Fix: Add phrases like 'Use when...', 'Triggers on...', or 'Applies to...' to help Claude select this skill
1.2-desc-whatline 3
Description missing WHAT clause (action verb) - recommended by agentskills spec
Fix: Consider starting with what the skill does, e.g., 'Creates...', 'Generates...', 'Validates...'
1.2-desc-whenline 3
Description missing WHEN clause - recommended by agentskills spec
Fix: Consider adding 'Use when...' or 'Activate when...' to description
12.3-workflow-vague-stepline 39
Step is too brief to be actionable: "**RICE Prioritizer**"
Fix: Add specific details: what, where, and how
12.3-workflow-vague-stepline 66
Step is too brief to be actionable: "**Persona Generator**"
Fix: Add specific details: what, where, and how
12.3-workflow-vague-stepline 90
Step is too brief to be actionable: "**Project Bootstrapper**"
Fix: Add specific details: what, where, and how
12.3-workflow-vague-stepline 98
Step is too brief to be actionable: "**PRD Templates**"
Fix: Add specific details: what, where, and how
12.3-workflow-vague-stepline 113
Step is too brief to be actionable: "**OKR Framework**"
Fix: Add specific details: what, where, and how
12.3-workflow-vague-stepline 118
Step is too brief to be actionable: "**Strategy Types**"
Fix: Add specific details: what, where, and how
12.3-workflow-vague-stepline 123
Step is too brief to be actionable: "**Persona Methodology**"
Fix: Add specific details: what, where, and how
12.3-workflow-vague-stepline 128
Step is too brief to be actionable: "**Example Personas**"
Fix: Add specific details: what, where, and how
12.3-workflow-vague-stepline 143
Step is too brief to be actionable: "**Component Architecture**"
Fix: Add specific details: what, where, and how
12.3-workflow-vague-stepline 148
Step is too brief to be actionable: "**Developer Handoff**"
Fix: Add specific details: what, where, and how
12.3-workflow-vague-stepline 153
Step is too brief to be actionable: "**Responsive Calculations**"
Fix: Add specific details: what, where, and how
12.3-workflow-vague-stepline 158
Step is too brief to be actionable: "**Token Generation**"
Fix: Add specific details: what, where, and how

Suggestions (10)

5.2-no-do-dontline 1
Missing DO/DON'T lists for style guidance
Fix: Add explicit DO and DON'T lists for writing patterns
16.4-no-idempotencyline 10
Skill does not document whether it is safe to re-run
Fix: Add idempotency guidance: state whether running the skill twice produces the same result or causes side effects
17.4-no-interface-sectionline 10
Input and output contracts exist but lack a dedicated interface section
Fix: Add a ## Interface or ## I/O section to consolidate contract documentation
3.4-gerund-namingline 2
Skill name could use gerund form for clarity
Fix: Consider gerund-style names like 'processing-pdfs' or 'analyzing-logs' (per best practices)
18.1-no-confidence-signalline 1
No confidence signal found for orchestrator decision-making
Fix: Add confidence indicators (e.g., confidence: high/medium/low) so orchestrators can route or retry
4.2-ambiguous-termline 264
Ambiguous term 'many' found
Fix: Replace with specific, measurable criteria
4.3-output-formatline 1
Skill mentions output but doesn't specify format
Fix: Add an '## Output' section with format examples
1.8-unexpected-fieldline 5
Unexpected frontmatter field 'domain'
Fix: Remove or move to metadata section. Valid fields: name, version, description, allowed-tools, compatibility, license, metadata
1.8-unexpected-fieldline 7
Unexpected frontmatter field 'tools'
Fix: Remove or move to metadata section. Valid fields: name, version, description, allowed-tools, compatibility, license, metadata
1.8-unexpected-fieldline 4
Unexpected frontmatter field 'skills'
Fix: Remove or move to metadata section. Valid fields: name, version, description, allowed-tools, compatibility, license, metadata
OWASP Agentic (Cat 26)
Agent surface detected — ingests external content; performs consequential actions
No deterministic OWASP signals on this agent surface.
ASI-01: passASI-02: skippedASI-03: skippedASI-04: skippedASI-05: skippedASI-06: skippedASI-07: skippedASI-08: skippedASI-09: skippedASI-10: skippedASI-11: skipped
Badges
skillcheck ✕ passed skillcheck ✕ antislop 100 skillcheck WCAG AA skillcheck WCAG AAA skillcheck enterprise
Ship with confidence

Get a report like this for your own skill

Run the free validator to see your structural score, then unlock the substance checks — anti-slop, security, accessibility, agent-readiness — that move a skill from valid to safe to ship.